| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| December 14, 2023 | (1) Billerica/Chelmsford Indians at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| December 16, 2023 | (0) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) Andover Golden Warriors | Breakaway Ice Center |
| December 20, 2023 | (1) Lincoln-Sudbury Warriors at (1) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| December 26, 2023 | (0) Westford Academy Ghosts at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials
Michael Giordano Christmas Classic |
Murphy Memorial Rink |
| December 27, 2023 | (1) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Boston Latin Wolfpack
Michael Giordano Christmas Classic-BL Wins title in SO |
Murphy Memorial Rink |
| January 06, 2024 | (1) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) HPNA Hillies
OT game ends in a tie |
Veterans Memorial Ice Rink |
| January 10, 2024 | (2) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Tewksbury/Methuen Red Rangers | Methuen High School Rink |
| January 13, 2024 | (3) Longmeadow Lancers at (1) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 17, 2024 | (1) Westford Academy Ghosts at (3) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 20, 2024 | (2) Shrewsbury Colonials at (0) Billerica/Chelmsford Indians | Hallenborg Memorial Pavilion |
| January 24, 2024 | (0) Andover Golden Warriors at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| January 27, 2024 | (1) Shrewsbury Colonials at (3) Lincoln-Sudbury Warriors | Valley Sports Arena |
| January 31, 2024 | (0) HPNA Hillies at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 03, 2024 | (1) Tewksbury/Methuen Red Rangers at (1) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 05, 2024 | (2) Acton-Boxboro Revolution at (6) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 10, 2024 | (2) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) Westford Academy Ghosts | Nashoba Valley Olympia |
| February 14, 2024 | (4) Algonquin/Hudson Titans at (1) Shrewsbury Colonials | NorthStar Ice Sports |
| February 17, 2024 | (6) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) Medway/Ashland Mustangs | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 19, 2024 | (6) Shrewsbury Colonials at (0) NSA - Norwell, Scituate, Abington Clippers
Newburyport Bank Classic - Doyle Divt |
Graf Rink |
| February 21, 2024 | (5) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Pope Francis Cardinals
Newburyport Bk Classic - Doyle Championship Game |
Graf Rink |
| February 28, 2024 | (1) Bishop Stang Spartans at (2) Shrewsbury Colonials
MIAA D1 Girls State Tournament - First Round |
NorthStar Ice Sports |
| March 02, 2024 | (4) Shrewsbury Colonials at (1) Bishop Feehan Shamrocks
MIAA D1 Girls State Tournament - Sweet 16 |
NorthStar Ice Sports |
| March 07, 2024 | (1) Shrewsbury Colonials at (2) St. Mary's Lynn Spartans
MIAA D1 Girls State Tournament - Elite 8 |
John A. Ryan Arena |
